The Secretary of the Commonwealth filed its first enforcement action under the Massachusetts Fiduciary Rule. Robinhood and its gamification of investing are in its bullseye.
The Massachusetts Securities Division adopted amendments to 950 Mass. Code Regs. 12.200 earlier this year as they relate to the standard of conduct applicable to broker-dealers and agents. The amendments apply a fiduciary conduct standard to broker-dealers and agents when dealing with their customers. The Division said it would begin enforcing the amended regulations on September 1, 2020.
“Each broker-dealer shall observe high standards of commercial honor
and just and equitable principles of trade in the conduct of its business.”
– 950 CMR 12.204(1)(a)
According to the data, Robinhood has almost a half million customers in Massachusetts. Approximately 68% of the Massachusetts customers approved for options trading on Robinhood have no or limited investment experience. One advertisement states:
“I’m a broke college student and investments might help my future tremendously.”
The administrative complaint shoots at Robinhood claiming its infrastructure is inadequate. The outages and disruptions in the platform earlier this year are the indicators. The crux of this prong of the complaint is that Robinhood is continuing to recruit new customers without properly improving its infrastructure. The complaint states 70 outages over the course of 2020.
The second prong of the complaint takes that position that Robinhood’s supply of lists of most popular stocks is an encouragement to purchase the security without consideration of the customer’s suitability.
The third prong is Robinhood’s permission and encouragement for customers to trade. The complaint uses the example of one customer that clicked the investment experience button when creating the account. That customer made 12,748 trades this year. An average of 92 trades a day.
A fourth prong is that Robinhood failed to properly screen customers before allowing them to trade options. Robinhood failed to follow its own policies and procedures.
Wrapping it up, the complaint says that each of these four prongs is a violation of the Massachusetts Fiduciary Standard applicable to broker-dealers.
All of this is just the regulators side of the case. A Robinhood spokeswoman said before the complaint was filed that the company has and will continue to work closely with all regulators.
“Robinhood has opened up financial markets for a new generation of people who were previously excluded.”
“We are committed to operating with integrity, transparency, and in compliance with all applicable laws and regulations.”
Sources: