Lynn Tilton and her firm, Patriarch Partners, are known for their high-risk, high-return investments in distressed companies. The Securities and Exchange Commission brought a case against her and the firm claiming that they were using improper valuations, failing to mark down assets when the investment became more distressed.
At this point we only have the SEC’s charges. According to a quote in the Wall Street Journal: “I’m choosing to fight,” Ms. Tilton said. “My reputation is very important to me and my companies. When my integrity or my intent are questioned, I fight back and let truth prevail.”
She will have to fight the SEC on its home turf. The SEC chose to bring the case as an action in its administrative court,s instead of federal district court. According to the Wall Street Journal the SEC brought the case through its in-house court in part to try to move the case quickly, since one of the funds at issue has a maturity date in November 2015.
Debt tends to be trickier to value than equity. There is the judgment call about how likely you are to have the debt repaid. This is even trickier with Patriarch where the debt is being used to fund the company’s turnaround being managed by Tilton and her companies. She would have the direct power or influence to determine when debt was repaid.
Patriarch’s valuation policy calls for current loans to be valued at the principal amount of the outstanding loan. A defaulted loan is supposed to be written down under the policy. The SEC viewed a default under the documents to be when the debtor fails to make an interest payment. According to the SEC, Tilton determined a loan in default when she will no longer provide financial and management support to the company.
In addition, the funds were supposed to have GAAP-compliant financial statements. Under GAAP, a loan is impaired, and must be measured for impairment when, based on all available information, it is probable that the creditor will be unable to collect all amounts due for interest and principal based on the contract with the debtor.
The difference in characterizing a default resulted in more than $200 million in fees earned on the higher valuations. It sounds like many of the problems could have been fixed with a stronger compliance program. Disclosure would have solved many of the issues in the SEC Order.
Sources:
- SEC Announces Fraud Charges Against Investment Adviser Accused of Concealing Poor Performance of Fund Assets From Investors
- SEC order against Tilton and Patriarch Partners
- ‘Diva of Distressed’ Tilton Is Facing SEC Action by Jody Shenn and Matthew Robinson in Bloomberg Business
- SEC Files Fraud Charges Against Lynn Tilton, Patriarch Partners by Matt Jarzemsky and Aruna Viswanatha in the Wall Street Journal
